In this groundbreaking book, scalia and garner systematically explain all the. Posner did not warmly embrace reading law, the book on textualism i coauthored with. Garner, all the most important principles of constitutional, statutory, and contractual interpretation are systematically explained in an engaging and informative styleincluding several hundred illustrations from actual cases. Justice scalia, with 25 years of experience on the supreme court, is the foremost expositor of textualism in the world today. Apr 28, 2007 legal writing expert bryan garner and justice antonin scalia combined forces to produce this book about the art of legal argumentation, both written and oral. Garner then wrote a letter to the new republic and posner has responded. This book presents every important idea about judicial persuasion in a fresh. Sep 11, 2012 smu dedman law provides research support for new book by supreme court justice scalia, bryan garner professor garner, editorinchief of blacks law dictionary, has been associated with smu dedman school of law since 1990 and became a distinguished research professor in 2008. Supreme court justice antonin scalia, with whom garner wrote two books in the. Aug 24, 2012 the passive view of the judicial role is aggressively defended in a new book by justice antonin scalia and the legal lexicographer bryan garner reading law. In scalias new book, hints of health ruling the new.
Oct 30, 2017 scalia speaks reflections on law, faith, and life well lived by antonin scalia edited by christopher j. Garner, all the most important principles of constitutional, statutory, and contractual interpretation are. Some thoughts on scalia and garners book reading law. In new book, scalia and garner attack unprincipled judicial. Scalia and garner release 567page tome on textualism. Jun 25, 2012 it is the approach that looks to the states brief, in its 12 point courier new glory with every other sentence in bold or italicized, to find a place to hang its hat. The interpretation of legal texts, the new treatise coauthored by justice antonin scalia and bryan a. The passive view of the judicial role is aggressively defended in a new book by justice antonin scalia and the legal lexicographer bryan garner reading law. Antonin scalias speeches, collected for arguments sake. The dissent, for instance, relies on an approach known as textualism, the subject of a new book by justice scalia, reading law. Political ideology aside i disagree with many of his opinions justice scalia was brilliant and his opinions were extremely well written. In this authoritative new book, scalia and garner demonstrate howespecially in the latter half of the 20th centuryinterpretative theorists encouraged judges to disregard governing texts and to do whatever they pleased in deciding cases. Bryan garner reflects on his friendship with justice antonin scalia in. It may well be, as i understand amars new book americas.
In this groundbreaking book, scalia and garner systematically explain all the most important principles of constitutional, statutory, and contractual interpretation. For almost thirty years, antonin scalia was arguably the most influential and controversial justice on the united states supreme court. There is no way to see it as other than a hatchet job an attempt to attack the book, without balance, from every possible direction. So, scalias and garners book, which is written to encourage better judicial reasoning and decisionmaking, could be a welcome addition to the bookshelves of many judges. A new book on statutory interpretation has just been published.
Jan 30, 2018 in his new book nino and me, readers are treated to the warm side of scalia the public rarely got to see. Bryan garner reflects on his friendship with justice. Garner s opinion is presented, justice scalia follows with his opinion and his analysis on why mr. Soon afterwards, tnr published an exchange between. In this groundbreaking book, scalia and garner systematically explain a. Jun 16, 2012 justice antonin scalia picked the right moment, then, to deliver more than 500 pages of hints, in a book to be published next week. Sep 12, 2012 scalia spat involving alleged misrepresentations in the new scaliagarner book. Jan 16, 2018 a justpublished book by legal writing expert bryan garner paints a new picture of the human side of the late u. This is a book written by bryan garner and justice antonin scalia. I dont know what answer scalia and garner would provide to amars question, nor am i ready to provide an offthecuff answer.
Posner on the incoherence of antonin scalia the new. Writing expert bryan garner doesnt pull punches in a new book about his partnership with the late antonin scalia. Federal courts and the law new edition university center. Two of the most prolific legal writers in the 20th and 21st century, that alone should be enough to get you to pick it up. Nov 17, 2012 meanwhile, garner the coauthor, went online defending his and scalia s use of the cases, suggesting posner completely missed the point of the book, and publicly taking posner to task for what garner apparently believes was the betrayal of a friendship. Supreme court justice antonin scalia and writing professional bryan a. Richard posner, richard posner responds to antonin scalias accusation of lying, the new republic, september 20, 2012. Jun 25, 2012 a new book on statutory interpretation has just been published. The interpretation of legal texts by antonin scalia. Scalia speaks reflections on law, faith, and life well lived by antonin scalia edited by christopher j. The art of persuading judges, a guide to lawyers on how to and how not to win the support of judges in litigation. So, scalia s and garner s book, which is written to encourage better judicial reasoning and decisionmaking, could be a welcome addition to the bookshelves of many judges. Intention and the canons of legal interpretation the new. Aug 01, 2012 some thoughts on scalia and garners book reading law.
The interpretation of legal texts and its by supreme court justice antonin scalia and usage guru bryan garner, who previously coauthored making your case. Scalias and garners new book suggests principled approach. Garner, as editor in chief of blacks law dictionary and author of garner s dictionary of legal usage, is the most renowned expert on the language of the law. Supreme court justice antonin scalia has agreed to a few select interviews to promote his new book, making your case.
It is the approach that looks to the states brief, in its 12 point courier new glory with every other sentence in bold or italicized, to find a place to hang its hat. Start reading scalia and garners reading law on your kindle in under a minute. In reading law, justice scalia and his coauthor, professor bryan. In this noteworthy book, two of the most noted legal writers of our day justice antonin scalia and bryan a. To bryan garner, editorinchief of blacks law dictionary, justice antonin scalia was a friend, a mentor, a collaborator and a fellow lover of words. Antonin scalia, born in trenton, new jersey, was an associate justice of the us. Jul 25, 2012 in a new book coauthored with bryan garner, scalia spells out his judicial philosophy, and on tuesday, the always voluble, charming and combative justice sat for a wideranging interview. New book on scalia bares turbulentand goodtimes with the.
The art of persuading judges scalia s involvement in this new project isnt surprising. Learn how antonin scalia helped change americas courts forever in our interview with his friend bryan garner, author of the new memoir nino and me. We interviewed garner, and asked him about scalia, their work, and its effects on. From legal expert and veteran author bryan garner comes a unique, intimate, and compelling memoir of his friendship with the late supreme court justice antonin scalia.
The art of persuading judges is a guide for novice and experienced litigators alike. The art of persuading judges antonin scalia, bryan a. Garner, who has now written two books with scalia, felt that it would be bad form to interrupt, but when the justice had trouble remembering the. Federal courts and the law new edition the university. The interpretation of legal texts posted on august 1, 2012 by ken adams over the past couple of days ive been dipping into the new book coauthored by antonin scalia and bryan garner, reading law. Justice antonin scalia picked the right moment, then, to deliver more than 500 pages of hints, in a book to be published next week. In this groundbreaking book, scalia and garner systematically explain all the most important principles of constitutional, statutory, and contractual interpretation in an engaging and informative style with hundreds of illustrations from actual cases. The key issue here is how judges and other interpreters should respond when the literal text seems to direct an absurd resultallowing, for. Where scalia and garner provide fiftyseven sound principles of interpretation, story offered his own nonexhaustive list of twentyone. Writing with antonin scalia, grammar nerd the new yorker. Apr 28, 2008 supreme court justice antonin scalia has agreed to a few select interviews to promote his new book, making your case. Garner systematically present every important idea about judicial persuasion in a fresh, entertaining way. Judge frank easterbrook calls the book a great event in american.
Jul 16, 2012 but scalia and garner are multiple authors, and i like any reader of their book have no trouble at all talking about what scalia and garner mean. In scalias new book, hints of health ruling the new york times. The incoherence of antonin scalia the new republic. Bryan garner, the legal writing guru, comes to the aid of his coauthor, justice antonin scalia. The interpretation of legal texts, scalia and garner appear to embrace an approach that would indeed allow vicepresidential selfdealing of this grotesque sort. While it will probably be of interest mostly to lawyers, it still has a lot of useful material for anyone who makes a living by either spoken or written persuasion. The new book is the second joint effort between scalia and garner. The art of persuading judges, written with lexicographer brian garner. The passive view of the judicial role is aggressively defended in a new book by justice antonin scalia and the legal lexicographer bryan garner. In this groundbreaking book by bestselling authors justice antonin scalia and bryan a. The book is a superb introduction to modern judicial decisionmaking. As with most hatchet jobs, it reflects as poorly on its author as on its target.
78 140 1651 881 202 551 930 979 1067 1240 699 1544 914 214 135 95 357 601 1052 540 1123 357 22 1589 359 570 318 1295 1071 1105 1268 306 577 663 1072 686